Kiwi Corbyn? Ideas are not enough

It’s an election year in New Zealand/Aotearoa. Around the world elections are proving to be wild and unpredictable. New political actors and organisations are arising from the margins, and the status quo is on the defensive. Its kicking off everywhere, except it seems, New Zealand.

In contrast to the rest of the world, NZ seems to be sleepwalking towards an election. If you want too see an ambitious, radical and progressive political voice, the options are sadly limited. For the radical left, the question is how do we turn this around? How can we build a radical political instrument to express the popular frustration with the status quo?

Its not an easy question to answer.

Political shake ups can look wildly different in different situations. Some countries have built new political parties from scratch, while elsewhere established formations have seen their elites displaced by internal rebellions. The shape of a radical revolt is hard to predict in advance, but with growing inequality and a large part of the population disengaged and frustrated, there is every reason to believe that could happen here too. But how?

Many who want to see this kind of rebellion start from the policy. “If only Labour/The Greens/New Party stood up for free education and healthcare, think of how popular it would be!”

This would only be a part of the picture. By itself policy is not enough. A radical politics is not new policies, but a new way of doing politics.

Jeremy Corbyn is a good example of this. It is true that Corbyn’s political positions were a departure from the Blairite Labour mainstream. But this was only part of the picture. Corbyn’s way of campaigning was also a radical leap.

Jez Corbyn’s campaign wasn’t dependent on big ticket funders and wooing the media. It was a turn to the grassroots. Corbyn put his trust in getting his message out directly, through mass rallies not prime time tv advertisements. And bringing together crowds of people helped create the energy to drive an army of volunteers, hitting the streets and winning over millions of in one-on-one conversations.

Radical politics is driven by popular participation. Its not just winning the debate with a good idea, its bringing thousands of new working class people into politics to campaign for these ideas.

In Spain, the radical party Podemos was built out of the “indignados” protests, where tens of thousands occupied town squares to protest against the corrupt politics of the status quo.

A NZ manifestation of the new left politics has to be more than just a new set of radical policies. For this departure to grow, it would to be built on top of new spaces for mass participation in radical politics.

In Aotearoa, it is still unclear where these energies will coalesce- in Labour, the Greens or Something new? But this doesn’t mean that leftists should wait for a socialist savior. We can’t invent a Corbyn, but by building activist campaigns and networks we create the social mass that can make it possible.

Comments welcome below. Please follow this blog.

Leftwin seeks to host a discussion on building a new left politics in Aotearoa/New Zealand.
Be part of that discussion.

1 thought on “Kiwi Corbyn? Ideas are not enough

  1. Quite right, radical politics is driven by popular participation. It is bringing thousands of people into politics to campaign for a specific ideology. And herein lays the problem. First, what is that ideology? If one looks at any of the Political parties campaigning today, all bar National and its acolytes, can be considered to be socially focused. Given that these “ideas” have not proved sufficiently attractive to the masses – what are these ideas?

    Secondly, implicit within your statement is that politics is the road to change – more accurately it is the motivation to vote in such number as to effect change. Given that more and more people are turning away from the polling booth, what can be done to mitigate this trend. The answer, again is the same – ideology!. It is the lack of a creditable alternative ideology that causes the masses to turn from the ballot box. In fact I shall be more specific – the issue is that all political parties, including those on the “left” all predicate their policies and ideology on the premise that Parliament has sovereign supremacy. This means that whomever is in Government are our masters – not our servants! The people do not care who holds the whip – the whip still falls across their backs, to one degree or another.

    If you wish to engage the people – then the ideology must be predicated on Sovereign supremacy as an extension of the peoples sovereignty and a subordinate Parliament. In New Zealand, this is already defined by Te Tiriti o Waitangi, however no party, including Maori, Mana, Labour or the Greens recognise Maori sovereign authority – all are seeking to Govern according to the Post-colonial model that has been thrust upon us by the British – in direct contravention to Te Tiriti o Waitangi. Should any party campaign on a platform that seeks to subordinate Parliament to a Maori Sovereign Authority, in accordance with Te Tiriti o Waitangi [Yes – actually honouring the Treaty] then perhaps this would give people the hope for the future.

    An actual sovereign entity that sets the direction for Government – outside party politics – gives a voice for the people and provides a platform for the people to exert their authority. Furthermore, such a sovereign framework enables an economic model based on sovereign control of the money supply rather than the current debt based model that is fueled by consumption and oxygenated by bank credit – sustained by the ever increasing exploitation of both people and resources. Now that is a ambitious, radical and progressive political ideology that would engage the masses – pity no one else is interested.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this:
search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close